Gates Memo: Appoints Task Force July 18, 2003

A 2-page memo appoints a task force to study the new admissions environment created by

Supreme Court rulings in Grutter and Gratz.

July 18 Memo [pdf 116k]

The memo raises several questions, mostly concerning its wide distribution. How could a

task force so widely known produce findings so carefully withheld?

For example, the memo

invites participation from the
speaker of the Faculty Senate and the chair of the

Advisory Committee. Yet the Task Force
report seems not to have been publicly introduced

either the Speaker or the Advisory Committee Chair
during Nov. 10 deliberations at the Faculty


Would the Faculty Senate decision have been affected
by fuller disclosure?

Was the Task Force report
considered by the Undergrad Admissions Committee?


the last line of the memo suggests a willingness
to “impact in a major way the excellence to which

aspire.” So what happened between July 18 and Aug.

Although the Task

Force indeed suggested major changes on Aug. 29, the cover memo also recognizes that the President is

reluctant to agree.

As for the “initial set of documents attached”, I have

copies of “confidential” legal advice that I
will be posting soon. The documents were provided

via open records requests.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: